Author Archives: andrew

John Button — a wrongful conviction, a disputed confession and the unanswered questions that remain

A conviction can be overturned – eventually. But what if the circumstances that caused the miscarriage of justice are never fully investigated, asks John Button, whose wrongful murder conviction led to 40 years of sorrow. Then came the 2024 refusal … Continue reading →

Posted in Case 33 John Button | Leave a comment

After 38 years in prison, Stephen ‘Shorty’ Jamieson dudded by heartless NSW Attorney-General Daley

More than four weeks after the petition asking the NSW Attorney-General to order a review of the unsafe murder conviction of Stephen ‘Shorty’ Jamieson, the reply demonstrates the stupor of our legal system when urgency is required. Here is the … Continue reading →

Posted in Case 28 Stephen Shorty Jamieson | Leave a comment

Lindsay Clancy – will the new trial reveal the real culprit?

Arguably the most controversial recent murder (mis)trial in the world will have an encore, but expect the verdict (whatever it is) to be controversial – and without an acknowledgement of the chemical fingerprints left by a modern psychiatric care system … Continue reading →

Posted in Case 32 Lindsay Clancy | Leave a comment

Father MacRae and question of guilt: AI unmasks media prejudice

After the 1994 (New Hampshire, US) trial and conviction of Fr Gordon MacRae of sexual offences involving a minor, some news outlets and others with an agenda cited a coerced post-trial plea as evidence of his guilt. It was no … Continue reading →

Posted in Case 24 Fr Gordon MacRae | 2 Comments

Meritless rape cases over several years finally blow up the system

Andrew L. Urban. As we wrote in September, “A sufficiently rigorous pre-trial assessment by a legally trained AI agent can identify important weaknesses in the prosecution theory before trial. Such a process can be used by counsel for either side … Continue reading →

Posted in General articles | 1 Comment

Rules for AI use in Tassie Supreme Court but short of reform

Andrew L. Urban. Tasmania’s Supreme Court has laid down the rules of AI use, in the wake of Parole Board’s AI generated erroneous submission in the Sue Neill-Fraser parole restrictions controversy. But the question is surely not whether AI is … Continue reading →

Posted in AI, General articles | 5 Comments

High Court to test Hanson’s “Go back home” text as a crime

Andrew L. Urban. Pauline Hanson’s Appeal will test the High Court, and reveal how the Racial Discrimination Act s 18C has a broader reach than its title might suggest. It may also embarrass the Federal Court. Importantly, the High Court … Continue reading →

Posted in General articles | 4 Comments

Starting AI at the crime scene on path to safer convictions

STEVEN FENNELL writes in response to Adrian Bertino-Clarke’s article, “What If Reviewing a Possible Wrongful Conviction Cost Almost Nothing?” published yesterday, expanding on the potential for AI to help reduce the incidence of wrongful convictions. I have no formal qualifications … Continue reading →

Posted in AI, General articles | 1 Comment

What If Reviewing a Possible Wrongful Conviction Cost Almost Nothing?

ADRIAN BERTINO-CLARKE asks what happens to the justice system when artificial intelligence makes it dramatically cheaper to question whether an old conviction is safe. 

Posted in General articles | 1 Comment

How pre-trial AI ‘fairness review’ could minimise wrongful convictions

Andrew L. Urban.  Prosecutors should not always need an AI agent to identify weaknesses in a circumstantial case. For instance, you don’t need to have been a trainee lawyer to have recognised that the police brief of the Sue Neill-Fraser … Continue reading →

Posted in AI, Case 01 Sue Neill-Fraser, General articles | 6 Comments