The prospect of an innocent person being convicted of a serious crime represents a catastrophic failure of the legal system.” The Chief Justice of England, Lord Igor Judge
Wrongful Convictions Report explores and exposes wrongful convictions and potential miscarriages of justice in Australia. WCR’s research goals include the establishment of a reliable database of wrongful convictions and an overview of identifiable reforms that would reduce the likelihood and incidence of such errors in the criminal justice system.
(Note: The archived articles from August 2013 to January 2018 were originally published in the Democracy & Justice section of our sister blog, pursuedemocracy.com and are still available there as well.)
Andrew L Urban
Tel: +61 414 949 670
Lindy Chamberlain – a catastrophic failure of the legal system
“A dingo took my baby!” became a derisive joke in the early 1980s, mocking Lindy Chamberlain, the mother who claimed to have seen a dingo leave the tent where her baby Azaria was sleeping, during a family barbecue one night at Uluru in the middle of Australia. The subsequent police investigation and her trial for the murder of her baby, Azaria, became the most famous case of a wrongful conviction in Australia.
(Photo courtesy Bobby Tamayo)
Armed with circumstantial evidence and watched by a mesmerised, judgemental Australia, the prosecution relied on forensic testimony that identified as blood splatter the material found splashed under the family car’s dashboard. Lindy had cut the baby’s throat with a pair of scissors, claimed the prosecution … It was six years after the baby’s death that more thorough forensic tests were undertaken. The material turned out to be sound deadener.
Chamberlain was convicted of murder on October 29, 1982; her appeals to the Federal Court and High Court were both dismissed. In February, 1986, after the discovery of a baby’s matinee jacket (on which her defence relied but which the police believed did not exist) partially buried in an isolated location, she was released. A year later her conviction was quashed. In 1992 the Australian Government paid her $1.3 million in compensation. In 2012, the fourth coronial inquest found that Azaria had died as a result of being attacked and taken by a dingo. Coroner Elizabeth Morris apologised to the Chamberlain family while an amended death certificate was immediately made available to them.
Forensic evidence has continued to be unreliable, police investigations continue to suffer from tunnel vision, circumstantial cases in particular continue all too often to result in wrongful convictions. And the process of correcting errors continues to be slow, cumbersome and weighted against the convicted.
Wrongful Convictions Report wishes to play a constructive role in persuading the legal system to adopt reforms that learn from errors of the past and that at least minimise the incidence of wrongful convictions.
Reforms needed include:
training to avoid ‘tunnel vision’ approach;
management culture to emphasise serving the court not the prosecution;
Forensic scientists, laboratories, professional bodies:
develop a system of quality standards, with documented policies and procedures;
training to avoid contextual bias;
Adherence to rules of law (e.g. not presenting speculation as fact);
Explain forensic evidence rationally;
Presentation of evidence fairly;
seeking conviction must be subservient to seeking of the facts & the truth;
Demand clarity and understanding by jury of scientific & forensic evidence;
Ensure prosecutors adhere to rules of trial behaviour and fairness
Networked Knowledge conducts research and publishes material in relation to wrongful convictions and miscarriages of justice in Australia and overseas. It has played a key role in the establishment of a new right of appeal in South Australia and Tasmania and in the overturning of the wrongful conviction of Henry Keogh in South Australia.