John Button: The Attorney General Said Investigations Established His Innocence. Where Are the Records?

Twenty-four years after his murder conviction was overturned, John Button has uncovered an extraordinary statement by a former Western Australian Attorney General, a juror’s firsthand account of a visit to the crime scene, and correspondence showing that two former detectives declined to be interviewed by the corruption watchdog. Yet the search for a reliable official account of what went wrong continues. 

In 1963, John Button was convicted of the manslaughter of Rosemary Anderson, the young woman he loved.

He was 19 years old. He had already suffered the devastation of Rosemary’s death. He then faced a murder prosecution, was convicted of manslaughter and spent approximately five years in prison.

For almost four decades, he carried the stigma of responsibility for Rosemary’s death.

In 2002, the Western Australian Court of Criminal Appeal quashed his conviction after fresh evidence undermined the prosecution case. Serial killer Eric Edgar Cooke had admitted responsibility for Rosemary’s death, while vehicle evidence raised fundamental doubts about the case against Button.

The conviction was overturned.

But what happened to the investigation of the original miscarriage of justice?

And why, more than six decades after the trial, is Button still struggling to obtain a full account of what went wrong?

Attorney General’s extraordinary admission

On 19 December 2007, Western Australian Attorney General Jim McGinty wrote to prominent barrister Malcolm McCusker QC concerning compensation for Peter and Raymond Mickelberg.

In that letter, McGinty compared their circumstances with those of John Button and Vincent Narkle.

He stated: “But Button and Narkle were undoubtedly wrongly convicted and investigations subsequent to their convictions conclusively established that each was innocent of the charges that had been brought against them.”

The Attorney General then referred to evidence of improper conduct and serious neglect or failure by investigating officers, particularly concerning the confessions obtained.

The significance of those words should not be underestimated. They were not written by Button or one of his supporters. They were written by the Attorney General of Western Australia.

The letter did not merely acknowledge that the Court of Appeal had quashed the conviction. It referred to subsequent investigations that had conclusively established innocence.

It also acknowledged evidence concerning the conduct of investigating officers.

What were those investigations?

Who conducted them?

When were they undertaken?

What documents, witness statements, reports or findings were produced?

And where are those records today?

McGinty’s letter does not identify the investigations. It does not establish that a separate formal inquiry was conducted or that particular officers were found to have committed misconduct.

But it creates an obvious and legitimate demand for an explanation.

If the Government relied upon investigations when describing Button’s innocence and the conduct of officers, it should identify the material on which that statement was based.

For Button, this is no longer merely a request to reconsider an old allegation. It is a request to explain the Government’s own words.

A juror’s account of a visit to the crime scene

Another important document has emerged from a woman who served on the jury at Button’s original trial.

Writing approximately 30 years after the proceedings, the former juror recalled that all the jurors were taken to the location where Rosemary was killed.

She wrote: “All the facts & evidence were presented to us there at that very area.”

The former juror also explained that she believed Button was innocent, but that she ultimately agreed to a manslaughter verdict after lengthy jury deliberations.

Her account is deeply troubling in human terms. It describes a juror who remained concerned about the verdict decades after the trial.

But it also raises a distinct procedural question. What happened when the jury visited the scene?

Button says he was not present.

John Button

He wants to know whether the judge and defence counsel attended, who addressed the jurors and whether information was presented outside the ordinary safeguards of the trial.

A jury visit to a crime scene was not necessarily unlawful. The important questions are how it was authorised and conducted and whether the accused’s procedural rights were respected.

The former juror’s recollection does not answer those questions.

Nor does her account of jury deliberations establish that the verdict was legally invalid; special evidentiary restrictions can apply to such material.

But her description provides a compelling reason to locate the original court records and determine what occurred.

The visit is not simply a historical curiosity. It concerns the circumstances in which a jury reached a verdict that cost Button years of his freedom.

Two detectives declined interviews with the corruption watchdog

Button subsequently complained to the Western Australian Corruption and Crime Commission about alleged misconduct during the original police investigation.

His concerns included the circumstances of his confession and the handling of blood evidence at the scene.

The CCC’s correspondence provides a revealing account of how those complaints were handled.

In a letter dated 7 May 2009, the Commission advised that his complaint had been referred to WA Police.

The Commission recorded that the police considered the events too old for further action and that those involved were no longer serving members.

The CCC agreed with the police position and closed the complaint.

A later complaint concerned Button’s allegation that police had moved or tampered with blood evidence.

On 27 June 2013, Acting Commissioner Neil Douglas wrote to Button explaining the Commission’s decision.

The letter recorded that former Detective Deering, then aged 85, had been approached but did not wish to be interviewed.

It also recorded that former Detective Wiley, then aged 88, had been approached but did not wish to be interviewed.

The Commission stated that declining an interview was their right.

The letter further explained that the Commission had been unable to identify Constable Wilson and considered the available evidence insufficient to support the allegation of blood-evidence tampering.

The Commission therefore closed the file.

The legal distinction is important.

The officers’ refusal to be interviewed did not establish misconduct. Nor was it the Commission’s only stated reason for declining further action.

But the correspondence raises a serious question about the practical limits of historical accountability.

When allegations concern events many decades old, when important witnesses cannot be interviewed and when records are incomplete, how can the public obtain an independent assessment of what happened?

The CCC was entitled to assess the evidence and exercise its statutory discretion.

The public is equally entitled to ask whether the available oversight mechanisms are adequate for examining the causes of a recognised miscarriage of justice.

Button’s complaint was closed. The larger historical questions remained.

The struggle to obtain records

In recent years, Button has attempted to obtain the records needed to answer those questions. His applications have involved the Department of Justice, the State Solicitor’s Office, the Department of the Premier and Cabinet, the State Records Office and the Supreme Court.

The correspondence reveals a difficult pattern.

One agency identifies another as the likely custodian.

An application is transferred.

Searches are conducted.

Clarifications are requested.

Decision dates are extended.

And, ultimately, the applicant is informed that the requested documents cannot be found or do not exist within the relevant agency’s holdings.

In one Freedom of Information matter, the Department of the Premier and Cabinet located records concerning Button but found none within the particular scope of his request about a historical inquiry.

In another, the State Solicitor’s Office upheld a refusal concerning records of the 1963 proceedings, while separately identifying three historical physical files and offering Button an opportunity to inspect them.

The State Records Office has identified the original Supreme Court case file, but advised that it had been recalled by the Court and remained subject to access restrictions.

These developments do not establish deliberate concealment.

But they expose the difficulty of reconstructing a miscarriage of justice when relevant records may be dispersed across multiple institutions.

A government agency may comply with its obligations under the Freedom of Information Act and still leave an important historical question unanswered.

The question for the public is whether this fragmented process is adequate.

Should someone whose conviction has been overturned be required to spend years searching agency by agency for records that might explain the injustice?

Or should there be a coordinated process for identifying, preserving and examining the surviving material?

Rosemary Anderson deserves an accurate historical record

Button has also sought further examination of Rosemary Anderson’s death.

His concern is that the historical understanding of her death should reflect the overturning of his conviction and the evidence implicating Eric Edgar Cooke.

He points to the Chamberlain case, in which a later coronial inquest formally identified a dingo as the cause of Azaria Chamberlain’s death.

The cases are not legally identical.

Western Australian authorities have advised that they could not locate historical coronial records concerning Rosemary and that no original inquest was held. Button has also been advised of the statutory process for requesting a further inquest.

Those matters must be resolved according to the applicable coronial legislation and evidence.

But the broader question remains.

When a conviction for a death has been overturned because of powerful fresh evidence, what responsibility does the State have to ensure that the surviving public record accurately reflects that development?

For Button, the issue is profoundly personal.

Rosemary was not merely the subject in a criminal charge. She was someone he loved.

His wish is that her death be understood accurately and that the stigma of responsibility no longer be attached to him.

The human consequences of institutional delay

A wrongful conviction is sometimes described as an error. But that word can obscure its consequences. Button lost years of liberty. He endured the destruction of his reputation. He lived with the accusation that he had killed Rosemary, despite maintaining that he had not struck her with his car.

His family lived with the consequences too.

The Court of Appeal eventually overturned his conviction, but no judgment could restore the decades already lost.

Now, in his eighties, Button continues to seek answers.

Every additional delay has a different meaning to him than it does to a government department. For an agency, a further month may be an administrative extension.

For Button, it is another month in a search that has already lasted much of his lifetime. And every year that passes risks making the surviving evidence harder to obtain.

The age of a case is a genuine obstacle to investigation. It should not become a substitute for explaining what records survive, what inquiries were conducted and what can still be established.

What the Government should now explain

The documentary record supports a number of specific questions.

First, what investigations did Attorney General McGinty mean when he wrote in December 2007 that investigations subsequent to Button’s conviction had conclusively established his innocence?

Second, what surviving court records explain the jury’s visit to the scene during the 1963 trial?

Third, what independent mechanism is available to assess credible historical allegations concerning a wrongful conviction where the CCC has declined further investigation?

Fourth, can the Government coordinate the identification of relevant records across the Supreme Court, the State Solicitor’s Office, the Department of Justice and other agencies?

Finally, what process is available to ensure that the historical record of Rosemary Anderson’s death properly reflects the evidence that led to Button’s conviction being overturned?

These are not demands that the Government declare particular people guilty without evidence.

They are demands for transparency, explanation and institutional accountability.

Justice must mean more than overturning a conviction

The Button case is no longer simply a story about a wrongful conviction in 1963. It is also a story about the decades that followed.

A conviction was overturned.

A former Attorney General subsequently wrote that investigations had conclusively established innocence and acknowledged evidence of improper investigative conduct.

A former juror described a visit to the crime scene that Button is still trying to reconstruct.

Two former detectives declined interviews when approached by the CCC.

And the search for historical records continues across multiple government agencies.

Each development has its own evidentiary limitations.

Together, they raise a powerful public-interest question.

When the justice system accepts that a man was wrongly convicted, who is responsible for establishing how it happened?

It is not enough to say that the conviction has been corrected.

The causes of wrongful convictions matter because the institutions that produced them continue to exercise power over other people’s lives.

Independent scrutiny is not an attack on the rule of law. It is one of the means by which the rule of law earns public confidence.

John Button has spent more than six decades living with the consequences of Rosemary Anderson’s death and his wrongful conviction of causing it.

He should not have to spend the remainder of his life navigating disconnected government offices in search of answers that the State itself once suggested had already been established.

The conviction was overturned in 2002. The unanswered questions remain in 2026. Justice requires more than correcting a verdict.

It requires the courage to explain how that verdict came about — and to change the system where the evidence shows change is necessary.

John & Rosemary

Mrs Anderson, Rosemary’s mother, was absolutely right when she said that I had taken her out that night and never brought her home.

Of that I am guilty, and I will suffer for the rest of my life in the knowledge that I failed to protect the girl I loved and cherished.

 

NOTE: This article is by John Button; it is in the third person because, as he explains: “As with all my texts, I run them through (legally trained) LIA because most involve legal issues.”

The John Button story

 

 

This entry was posted in Case 33 John Button. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.