John Button — a wrongful conviction, a disputed confession and the unanswered questions that remain

A conviction can be overturned – eventually. But what if the circumstances that caused the miscarriage of justice are never fully investigated, asks John Button, whose wrongful murder conviction led to 40 years of sorrow. Then came the 2024 refusal by WA Attorney-General John Quigley to investigate the process that delivered such injustice. It is a “story of grief, imprisonment, despair, faith, family and the long struggle to rebuild a life.” 

On 9 February 1963, a young woman named Rosemary Anderson was struck by a vehicle in Stubbs Terrace, a very, very long, mostly straight, underdeveloped suburban road in Perth, WA, parallel to the railway line, running through Shenton Park.

She died from her injuries.

John Button at 18 (supplied)

Her boyfriend, John Button, was devastated. The young couple had argued earlier that evening, and Rosemary had walked away. Within hours, Button found himself accused of deliberately running her down. He was charged with wilful murder, an offence that at the time could carry the death penalty. It was his 19th birthday.

Button maintained that he had not struck Rosemary with his car. Nevertheless, following police questioning, he made a confession that became central to the prosecution case.

He was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to ten years’ imprisonment.

He served approximately five years before being released on parole in 1967.

But leaving prison did not end his punishment.

For decades, Button lived with the consequences of a conviction for causing the death of the young woman he had loved.

A confession that should have been questioned

One of the most troubling features of the Button case was the confession obtained during police questioning.

Button has consistently maintained that the confession was false.

In his autobiography, Why Me Lord!, and in subsequent correspondence, he describes the emotional devastation he experienced following Rosemary’s death and the circumstances in which he came to confess.

In a letter to Western Australian Attorney General John Quigley dated 27 September 2023, Button alleged that he had been physically assaulted during questioning. He described repeatedly denying responsibility before eventually agreeing to confess after being told Rosemary was dead.

These are serious allegations about the conduct of the investigation.

The importance of the confession raises a fundamental question:

How reliable is a confession when the circumstances in which it was obtained are themselves disputed?

A confession can be powerful evidence. But its reliability must be assessed against the circumstances of questioning and the independent physical evidence.

In Button’s case, later examination of that evidence raised substantial doubts about whether his vehicle had struck Rosemary at all.

The man who really confessed to Rosemary’s death

The case took another extraordinary turn when serial killer Eric Edgar Cooke admitted responsibility for Rosemary Anderson’s death.

Cooke was responsible for a series of violent crimes in Perth, including attacks involving motor vehicles.

He maintained his responsibility for Rosemary’s death in a confession made shortly before his execution in 1964.

Yet Button’s conviction remained in place for decades.

The competing confessions created an obvious problem. If Cooke was responsible, Button’s confession could not be a truthful account of the fatal collision.

The question was not simply which man had confessed.

It was which account was supported by the independent evidence.

The physical evidence that changed the case

Decades later, fresh evidence concerning Button’s Simca motor vehicle became critically important.

Trevor Condren, a police vehicle examiner who had inspected the Simca in 1963, subsequently gave evidence that he had formed the opinion at the time that the vehicle had not struck a pedestrian.

He had not expressed that opinion in his original trial evidence.

Further evidence from accident reconstruction expert Mr Haight supported the conclusion that the damage to Button’s vehicle was inconsistent with the alleged collision.

This was significant because the prosecution case had depended upon Button’s vehicle being responsible for Rosemary’s injuries.

The fresh evidence also provided support for Cooke’s account.

Other evidence concerning the position of Rosemary’s body and the observations of witnesses raised further questions about the original reconstruction of events.

In 2002, the Western Australian Court of Criminal Appeal quashed Button’s conviction.

Nearly forty years after Rosemary’s death, the conviction that had shaped his life was finally overturned.

When the courts correct a miscarriage of justice

The successful appeal was a major achievement.

The court recognised that the fresh evidence was sufficient to undermine the safety of Button’s conviction.

In particular, the accident reconstruction evidence, the observations of the vehicle examiner and Cooke’s admissions provided powerful grounds for questioning the original verdict.

But the outcome also exposed a disturbing reality.

Important evidence capable of challenging the prosecution case had not been properly placed before the original jury.

The conviction had survived for decades despite the existence of another man’s confession.

And the consequences for Button could never be undone.

He had lost years of his freedom, suffered the stigma of conviction and endured the lasting emotional consequences of being held responsible for Rosemary’s death.

The successful appeal corrected the legal outcome.

It did not restore the years that had been taken from him.

The questions that remain unanswered

For John Button, the overturning of his conviction was not the end of the matter.

In his September 2023 letter to Attorney General John Quigley, he called for a full and open inquiry into the circumstances of his arrest, interrogation and conviction.

He raised allegations concerning police conduct, the handling and presentation of evidence, and the failure to disclose information that might have assisted his defence.

One particular concern involved the location of bloodstained sand at the scene of Rosemary’s death.

Button contends that the physical evidence and eyewitness observations were inconsistent with the position later attributed to the bloodstaining. He believes this raises questions about whether evidence was moved or misrepresented.

That allegation requires independent examination. The fact that the conviction was overturned does not, by itself, establish deliberate evidence tampering or criminal misconduct by particular officers.

Nevertheless, the questions are important.

If material evidence was withheld, misrepresented or improperly handled, how did that happen?

Who knew about it?

Why was the defence not given the full benefit of potentially exculpatory evidence?

And why should the correction of a wrongful conviction necessarily mark the end of official scrutiny?

Compensation without full accountability?

Following the overturning of his conviction, Button received an ex-gratia payment from the Western Australian Government.

But he has questioned the transparency of the process used to determine such payments.

In his letter to John Quigley, Button argued that people who have suffered wrongful convictions should be entitled to understand how compensation decisions are made, what information is considered and how the amounts awarded are calculated.

He also called for independent inquiries into the causes of wrongful convictions.

His concern raises a broader issue.

Should compensation for a miscarriage of justice be determined through a discretionary government process without a full public explanation of how the miscarriage occurred?

An ex-gratia payment may provide financial recognition of an injustice.

But it does not necessarily establish legal liability, determine whether individual officials acted improperly or provide a public account of institutional failure.

Nor can money restore the years spent in prison or remove the suffering experienced by families.

If the causes of a miscarriage of justice are not properly examined, the opportunity to prevent similar failures may be lost.

The human cost behind the legal decision

In Why Me Lord!, Button tells a story that extends far beyond the courtroom.

It is a story of grief, imprisonment, despair, faith, family and the long struggle to rebuild a life.

He writes of his love for Rosemary, whose death remained a defining tragedy, and of Helen, the woman who subsequently became his wife and whose support helped him through the years that followed.

John Button in 1962 (suppled)

His account illustrates something that legal judgments cannot fully capture. A wrongful conviction does not affect only the person imprisoned. It affects parents, partners, children and generations of family members.

It can destroy reputations, damage relationships and leave emotional consequences long after the prison gates have opened.

For Button, the fight for justice became a struggle not only to clear his name but also to understand why the system had failed him.

The difference between a corrected conviction and complete justice

John Button’s case demonstrates that the criminal justice system is capable of correcting a serious mistake.

But it also demonstrates how long that correction can take.

The original conviction was entered in 1963.

It was not overturned until 2002.

For almost four decades, Button carried the burden of a conviction that the appellate court ultimately set aside.

His case also raises a question extending beyond his personal experience.

When a wrongful conviction is recognised, should the responsibility of the justice system end with the appeal?

Or should there be an independent examination of how the conviction occurred, whether official conduct contributed to it and what safeguards are necessary to prevent a recurrence?

The interests of justice extend beyond the acquitted or exonerated person.

They include the victim, the victim’s family and the community’s right to have confidence that criminal investigations are conducted fairly and reliably.

Would an inquiry achieve nothing?

In September 2024, John Button received a response from the office of Western Australian Attorney General John Quigley concerning his request for an independent inquiry into the circumstances of his wrongful conviction.

The response acknowledged the injustice Button had suffered but declined his request.

It stated: “Given the length of time since the events in question, an inquiry into your arrest and conviction is not feasible and could not achieve the outcomes you seek.”

That statement raises an important question.

How can it be determined that an inquiry could not achieve its objectives without first examining what evidence remains available and what questions could still be answered?

The passage of time undoubtedly creates difficulties. Witnesses die, memories fade and documents may be lost.

But historical inquiries are not necessarily undertaken solely to establish criminal responsibility or obtain compensation.

They can also examine institutional failures, identify how miscarriages of justice occurred and recommend changes to prevent similar injustices.

Button’s conviction was overturned in 2002. Yet his request for a public examination of the circumstances leading to that conviction has not resulted in the inquiry he seeks.

The Attorney General’s office acknowledged the injustice but considered a further inquiry impracticable.

That leaves a fundamental question unanswered: If the passage of time is sufficient reason not to investigate a recognised miscarriage of justice, does the longer an injustice remains unresolved make official accountability less likely?

The importance of an inquiry should not be measured solely by whether it can provide a remedy to the individual concerned.

It should also be measured by what it may reveal about the administration of justice and what future injustices it might help prevent.

The need for reform

Miscarriages of justice are not merely historical mistakes.

They expose weaknesses that may remain within the institutions responsible for investigating and prosecuting crime.

A justice system worthy of public confidence must be prepared not only to overturn unsafe convictions but also to examine their causes.

That requires genuine transparency, preservation and disclosure of evidence, independent scrutiny of credible allegations of misconduct, and fair processes for assessing compensation.

It also requires recognising that a jury can reach an incorrect verdict when important evidence is missing, unreliable or misunderstood.

John Button eventually obtained the legal vindication he had sought for decades.

But his continuing call for an inquiry raises a question that the overturning of his conviction alone cannot answer:

If the justice system acknowledges that an innocent person was wrongly convicted, should it not also be prepared to explain how that injustice was allowed to happen? Justice must do more than correct its mistakes.

It must be willing to investigate them.

“Why Me Lord” by John Button available on Amazon

NOTE: This article is by John Button; it is in the third person because, as he explains: “As with all my texts, I run them through (legally trained) LIA because most involve legal issues.”

COMMENT by Andrew L. Urban

Yet another example of disgraceful behaviour by Australia’s “justice” system, John Button’s experience demonstrates not only how inefficient the system sometimes is in the pursuit of solving crimes – but in correcting its mistakes. How does the (wealthy) legal profession sleep at night? It should be collectively outraged and/or shamed at its lack of enthusiasm to pursue remedies for its many tragic failures. Our legal system seems to have learnt nothing over the decades about protecting the innocent in criminal investigations and trials. Two decades after the John Button mistake came the Lindy Chamberlain mistake and the Derek Bromley mistake …followed by too many others, not least Sue Neill-Fraser, Robert Xie, etc, etc. Just look at our menu on the right. The only rational conclusion open to those paying attention is that our legal system is not fit for purpose without reforms.

This entry was posted in Case 33 John Button. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.