More than four weeks after the petition asking the NSW Attorney-General to order a review of the unsafe murder conviction of Stephen ‘Shorty’ Jamieson, the reply demonstrates the stupor of our legal system when urgency is required. Here is the response from Michael Daley MP in full:
I refer to the ePetition presented by the Honourable Sue Higginson MLC on 13 October 2026. This petition requests a public response to the open memorandum from Professor Helen Fraser and Professor Michele Ruyters titled ‘DNA and false confession evidence warrant an inquiry into the 1990 conviction and life sentence of Stephen ‘Shorty’ Jamieson’.
The matters raised in the petition regarding Mr Jamieson’s conviction for the death of Janine Balding have been noted. I also acknowledge the work of Professors Fraser and Ruyters, including their request for the release of the Cerduna Report by the Police Integrity Commission. I note NSW Police Force conduct falls outside my portfolio responsibilities.
In relation to the request for a review into Mr Jamieson’s conviction, he may wish to consider the options available under Part 7 of the Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001. The mechanisms under Part 7 are important for preserving public confidence in the administration of justice and safeguarding against miscarriages of justice.
This is an unconscionable, shameful, heartless response. Stephen “Shorty” Jamieson is 37 years into a life sentence arising from an alleged confession documented only by an uncorroborated “verbatim record of interview” typed by detectives who arrested him in 1988. His appeal was unanimously dismissed by the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal in 1992. His subsequent High Court special leave application was also dismissed. He also made an earlier application for an inquiry in 2001 under the predecessor review provisions, which was dismissed.

Stephen Shorty Jamieson (HANDOUT/Nine News) Credit: AAP
He was convicted alongside four co-accused. For Jamieson, the later availability of Mark Wells’ DNA profile and the proposed comparison with the bandana provide a potentially significant new evidentiary dimension. The competing identification of Jamieson and Mark Wells is central to the case.
The 2025 Supreme Court judgment records that:
- Wells was known by the same nickname, Shorty.
- Wells was of similar stature.
- Wells also wore bandanas.
- Co-accused gave evidence that Wells, rather than Jamieson, was the relevant person present with the group.
Jamieson suffers documented intellectual impairment, with an IQ reported to be approximately 65. There is also published discussion of possible Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder and concerns and about his capacity to understand and formulate complex information. He has potential difficulties with comprehension, reasoning and communication.
The legal system, from the (discredited) detectives who originally questioned him to the appeal courts, has treated Jamieson despicably – and now continues to do so. The Attorney-General should have immediately ordered an urgent review of Shorty’s case.